Is your renewal forecast as strong as it looks?

What boards should hear from Customer Success before backing next year’s plan.

1 Nov 2026 · Josh Morse

Is your renewal forecast as strong as it looks?

As boards review their 2027 plans, investors are asking me how to judge whether Customer Success is working. GRR looks healthy, the account health scores are green, and leadership forecasts the customer base to expand. They want to know how solid those projections are.

The challenge is that Customer Success looks different across an investor’s portfolio. Scope and ownership vary, the function often developed after Sales and Marketing. It is less well defined, and the person leading it hasn’t always been intentionally developed as the business grew. Yet next year’s plan assumes customers will stay and spend more.

One of the best CROs I’ve worked with was from Madrid, but always on a plane to be in person with customers and his team. I remember his view on a close to $1m new logo deal where the buyer would only commit to a one year contract. We had a 130% net revenue retention target. In the deal review his focus was already on the renewal. He only wanted it signed if we could deliver the value the customer needed. Retaining that million meant finding another $300k of growth. Losing it meant finding $1.3m. He wasn’t interested in winning the quarter, his focus was on building a compounding business.

Why the usual response falls short

Often a spike in the churn rate arrives unexpectedly. The last board pack was covered with green and a healthy renewal forecast. As the termination notices start coming in, the leadership first concentrates on upcoming renewals to remove surprises from the next quarter. The exec make more time to join customer calls. The team books more meetings, revisits health scores and explains how it will save the accounts now considered at risk.

The rescue starts after the decision, without changing how the team spots risk.

At one scaleup I worked with, every quarter brought the same focus on the next 90 days. High growth and a love of OKRs had led to a focus on immediate metrics. The problem was that the customers who had already decided to move on and communicated it internally had done so long before their renewal date. Saving them meant persuading someone to reopen that decision and spend political capital.

At another company, they took the PLG approach of product usage determining churn risk, even though they sold to mid market and enterprise. The board were happy to hear six months out from renewal that recovering usage meant they were no longer at risk. When the customer gave notice, the loss review found that the increased usage was from users exporting data and downloading files before moving to another platform.

The customer was preparing to leave while the reporting became more reassuring.

A reliance on NPS and product usage doesn’t work outside of smaller ACVs. The people deciding whether to keep paying may never log in. I’ve seen many happy customers churn. Liking the product and vendor doesn’t mean they can justify the spend. Successful customers rarely leave. Success being the business impact the economic buyer approved the spend to achieve.

The board’s test is whether Customer Success can show what customers need to achieve and how they’re tracking against it. Confidence in the renewal forecast depends on evidence of risks spotted early and action taken while the customer’s decision could still change.

The renewal date tells the board when the contract ends. It doesn’t tell the board when the customer decided.

What the board needs to hear

These customers are falling short of the outcomes they bought us for.
I want to hear which outcomes are falling short, what’s preventing them and who will act. That includes the view of whoever decides whether the spend remains justified. Regular meetings with happy users offer little comfort if the budget holder sees no reason to renew. Delivering the original business case doesn’t guarantee renewal when priorities change, vendors get consolidated or customers build alternatives with AI. Customer Success has to know whether the reason to keep paying still holds.

Expansion can cover losses elsewhere. A healthy net revenue retention figure can conceal customers churning or cutting their spend. Gross retention exposes that loss before expansion offsets it. Differences by segment, product and cohort deserve an explanation of what customers are experiencing and what management is doing about it.

We caught these risks early. We should have caught these others sooner.
A departing champion can create a new risk. Discovering that a customer has spent months preparing to switch exposes a different problem. Ask when the trigger for the risk happened, when the team recognised it and what happened next.

That assessment has to cover the whole customer base, including customers still onboarding and those whose renewal is some way off. Ask what changes an account’s risk assessment and how previous assessments compared with actual losses. Different CSMs shouldn’t assign different probabilities to the same evidence.

These renewals require investment.
Some companies sell churn.

They win customers whose requirements the product can’t meet, or make promises that become someone else’s problem after signature. I’ve also seen the product roadmap become focused on opening up a new segment and Product Market Fit starts to drift in the wrong direction. A capable CS leader exposes those patterns and makes clear who owns the response.

Product dependencies belong beside the forecast. If £3m of an £8m renewal forecast depends on a planned release, the board needs to see that exposure and what happens if delivery slips. A customer saying they won’t renew without a feature is different from one asking for it.

Holding CS accountable for retention doesn’t give it control over what Sales promises or Product delivers. Before questioning the leader’s ability to retain those customers, check whether the business has given them a problem they can solve.

Sales and Customer Success have a documented playbook and these are the latest improvements.
When I took over Sales and Customer Success at one company, Account Managers and CSMs attended the same meetings. Sales sometimes picked up CS’s work because they thought they’d do it better. There was friction between the teams, while customers with expansion potential were left to one side.

We worked through which customers needed what from us, who would handle each part and where the teams needed coaching. CS took more of the lead on customer issues. Account Managers had time for neglected expansion opportunities. Customers knew who to contact.

A lean team covered more customers, identified risk earlier and increased expansion revenue and NRR.

We found the same problem in other accounts and these are the actions we have taken.
A useful churn review changes what happens next. I want to hear whether management checked other customers for the same warning signs, what it found and what changed.

Otherwise, the company can explain each departure individually while repeatedly missing the same problem.

What the board needs to hear from Customer Success: five statements to listen for, backed by evidence, from customers falling short of their outcomes and risks caught early or late, through renewals that need investment and the Sales and CS playbook, to finding the same problem in other accounts and acting on it.

What the board should hear about AI

If AI is removing administration, where is your team’s time going, and what are customers getting from it?

This is where we’re spending the time we’ve freed up.
How much time has been saved? Which customers now receive more attention, and why? That might mean helping new customers through difficult early stages or reaching accounts the team previously neglected.

More meetings prove little. Your customers don’t need another vendor booking a QBR to fill its calendar. The additional contact should have a purpose the customer would recognise.

We’re finding signs of intent beyond product usage.
Customers reading guidance about exporting data or closing their account could be exploring their options. Job adverts naming different technology are another reason to look closer. AI can help surface those signals alongside customer conversations and account history.

Neither signal proves an intention to churn. The board should hear what the team investigated, what it learned and whether it acted while the decision was still open. Another queue of alerts leaves that work unfinished.

This is the coaching the team needs to make that time useful.
A CSM who spent much of their week preparing reports won’t automatically become effective at challenging a customer or discussing the business case with a senior buyer.

The leader captures what the strongest CSMs notice and do. AI uses that standard to prepare customer conversations and review them afterwards, spreading good practice across the team.

An example of a conversation the team handles better after coaching gives the board more to work with than an assurance that training is underway. If the leader can’t identify those gaps, the CEO should consider what support would help them do so.

These are the first improvements we expect to see.
If AI frees the team to help customers achieve results sooner, earlier customer outcomes and fewer unresolved delays should appear before renewal rates change.

If management claims earlier risk detection, ask how much time the team now has to act and what it’s doing with that time. An increase in flagged accounts can initially reflect better visibility.

Review those results before accepting a proposed increase in customers or revenue per CSM. Time saved doesn’t establish how effectively it will be used.

Customer Success, what the board should hear about AI: freed-up time reaches new and neglected customers, signs of intent surface beyond product usage, the team acts while the decision is still open, AI spreads what the strongest CSMs notice and do and coaching shows up in better conversations, leading to earlier outcomes and fewer unresolved delays.

This Week’s Tangible Prompt

Three things to ask at your next board meeting.

  1. What percentage of customers renewing next year are achieving the business outcomes they bought us for?
    Separate customers whose business case we don’t understand from those where we can’t quantify progress or aren’t delivering the intended result. Ask how much renewal revenue sits in each group and what management is doing about it.
  2. How much of our churn and contraction did we forecast six months before it happened?
    Compare actual losses with the forecast recorded at the time. For material surprises, check when the customer decided, when the company found out, and whether anyone engaged while the decision could still change. Separate genuinely new events from information discovered late, then check what changed elsewhere in the customer base.
  3. Where will AI release time, how will we use it, and what should improve first?
    Connect the capacity gained to customer needs and the coaching required. Agree which early results the board will review before assuming better retention or approving more accounts per CSM.

Answering these questions properly will take work outside the board meeting. Before backing more CS headcount or making decisions on the existing team, establish whether customers are being lost through poor fit, product gaps or problems the team should have addressed. The default fix of changing people without ensuring you have a complete picture means that new people will inherit whichever of those the business leaves unresolved.

← All essays

Josh Morse

Reading is free. Waiting isn't.

If an essay hit a nerve, that nerve is usually worth a conversation.

Book a call →
×

Get the essays before your competitors do.

New essays land here first. Free, weekly, unsubscribe whenever.