Missed forecasts are the smoke

The questions boards should ask when the forecast keeps moving.

24 Oct 2026 · Josh Morse

Missed forecasts are the smoke

For a lot of companies, we’re now in the final quarter. It’s become clear where they’ll finish the year, and how far that is from the numbers the board has been hearing along the way.

I often get asked by investors to help improve forecasting in scale-ups, particularly in the year after their first institutional investment. The current quarter’s forecast changes materially after a month. A future quarter looks good, then drops just before it starts. The reasons sound reasonable. But after a few cycles, the board starts asking why the original forecast didn’t account for them.

I never get asked for help when a company exceeds its forecast.

When it comes to GTM, boards want the company to hit the number and avoid surprises. They’ve committed money, backed hiring plans and set expectations. When planning next year, every surprise erodes trust in what they’re being told.

That matters particularly where sales cycles last more than a quarter. The board needs confidence in the annual outlook, including the opportunities supporting quarters that haven’t started yet.

Why the usual fix falls short

After the forecast moves for the second or third time, the response usually centres on forecasting process and discipline. More forecast calls. Better CRM records. Support for the revenue leader in assessing and communicating the number.

Improving forecasting skills helps. Some leaders need guidance as the business becomes larger and more demanding. But a tighter forecasting process can keep everyone busy with the smoke while leaving the fire untouched.

Every rep interprets customer conversations and data differently. They make their own judgements about qualification, progress and when a deal might close. Unless the revenue leader establishes a common approach, the forecast becomes a patchwork quilt of those individual interpretations.

An up-to-date CRM can still contain opportunities the team hasn’t understood well enough to forecast. More pressure to commit won’t supply the missing customer information.

The board’s task is to establish whether the revenue leader understands those gaps, is addressing them consistently and needs support to do so.

What the board needs to hear

Listen for statements like these, backed by evidence.

These opportunities had information gaps we should have closed earlier.
Some deals will be lost. Others will slip because something genuinely changed later in the sale. Ask the revenue leader to distinguish those changes from information the team discovered late. The explanation should identify what was missing, when it became known and how the team will uncover it earlier next time.

This is how we’ve tightened early discovery around urgency and the buying process.
I learned the hard way that a strong forecast and win rate start in the first few customer interactions. Discovery, a clear reason to act and an understanding of how the customer will buy help the rep progress the deal as well as assess it. The board should hear which weaknesses were found and what has changed in the evidence supporting new opportunities and their close dates.

Our pipeline reviews flag stalled opportunities between forecast calls.
I also learned how easily late-stage deals consume everyone’s attention. Earlier opportunities lose momentum while the team chases the quarter. Reps eventually revisit those neglected deals and move the dates or close them out. Ask how the leader is detecting that drift, including through AI, and what has been addressed before it became another forecast change.

Here is how AI is supporting coaching, and what has improved.
At one company recently, call reviews exposed reps regularly finishing meetings without agreeing and booking the next step. The team made that a coaching focus. Deals progressed faster, reps spent less time chasing customers, and prospects unwilling to commit became easier to challenge or qualify out.
That is the kind of evidence the board should hear. Even successful, fully ramped reps need regular feedback. Ask where coaching is making a difference and who is supporting the revenue leader’s own development.

We’ve adjusted this segment’s forecast assumptions using its own results.
Two opportunities at the same CRM stage can have very different chances of closing. Historical win rates and sales cycles from an established segment may misrepresent a new segment or product. The revenue leader should explain which assumptions have changed, what evidence supports the adjustment and where the company is still learning. A weighted pipeline figure needs that explanation behind it.

These are the material findings from last quarter and the changes we’ve made.
Wins, losses and slipped deals should inform the approach. Ask what the team learned and what changed as a result. A focused deal and process review can help uncover the causes, but that work belongs outside the board meeting. The CEO and revenue leader should bring back the findings, the action taken and where further guidance is needed.

What the board needs to hear on the forecast: six statements to listen for, backed by evidence, from information gaps the team should have closed earlier and tighter discovery on urgency and buying, through reviews that flag stalled deals and AI-supported coaching, to adjusted segment assumptions and last quarter’s findings with the changes made.

What the board should hear about AI

Using AI to analyse the CRM should now be a basic expectation in AI Era GTM. But a summary of the database is only the first step.

The board needs confidence that AI is helping the team find risks earlier and improve the evidence behind the forecast. Five checks matter.

Customer evidence is being captured, with gaps made visible.
Establish whether meetings, calls, emails and engagement data are captured and connected to the relevant accounts and opportunities. The revenue leader should be able to explain where coverage remains incomplete and how those gaps affect confidence in the forecast.

Agents keep records current and flag changes that need attention.
Ask whether the reviews identify stalled activity, changes in engagement and close dates that lack supporting evidence. There should be a named owner for checking important findings and acting on them. A useful update includes what was caught early and what happened next.

AI uses the company’s sales approach and customer context.
Establish whether the reviews reflect different segments, buyer roles and purchasing processes, alongside the company’s standards for discovery, demos and competing effectively. Those definitions need to be shared and kept current. Otherwise, different interpretations can produce apparently comparable assessments that mean different things.

Qualification gaps surface early enough to address.
If the team uses a framework such as MEDDPICC, ask whether customer evidence supports the dates and stages, and whether that evidence arrives early enough. A completed record offers little reassurance if the team only establishes urgency or the route to purchase as the forecast quarter approaches.

The findings lead to focused coaching without overwhelming the team.
Ask how the revenue leader selects the priorities and checks whether coaching changes customer interactions. The evidence should include stronger engagement, clearer reasons to act or more dependable next steps. The board needs to know that the team is improving, rather than simply receiving more assessments.

Sales forecast, what the board should hear about AI: customer evidence is captured with gaps visible, agents keep records current and flag changes, AI uses your sales approach and customer context, qualification gaps surface early enough to address and findings lead to focused coaching, so risks are found earlier with better evidence behind the forecast.

This Week’s Tangible Prompt

Three things to ask at your next board meeting

  • Review the quarters ahead.
    Give the next quarter proper attention alongside the current one, and look further out where the sales cycle requires it. Ask for risk, upside and uncertainty across the annual forecast. Otherwise, opportunities can keep slipping before they ever reach the quarter the board is watching.
  • Ask what wins, losses and slips are changing.
    Look for a clear connection between the findings and improvements in the sales approach. Ask whether differences in forecast accuracy between reps reveal recurring gaps, and whether the leader is addressing them. You need the patterns and the response, rather than everyone’s individual scorecard.
  • Check that the weekly review produces action.
    Ask what the process flagged early, what the revenue leader did and when the CEO heard about material changes. At subsequent meetings, look for evidence that the method is improving, rather than another assurance that the team has reviewed the pipeline.

Before backing more Sales hiring, establish whether a new rep can learn an approach the existing team uses consistently. Where that approach is weak, agree the development and practical guidance the revenue leader needs to strengthen it.

The same gaps that make deals difficult to forecast can make them difficult to win. Understanding those gaps gives the board a much stronger basis for deciding whether the Sales function is ready to scale, and what support its leader needs before it does.

← All essays

Josh Morse

Reading is free. Waiting isn't.

If an essay hit a nerve, that nerve is usually worth a conversation.

Book a call →
×

Get the essays before your competitors do.

New essays land here first. Free, weekly, unsubscribe whenever.